Last Monday marked a state-level win for reining in unchecked money in politics: the Texas Ethics Commission now requires that dark money groups disclose their donors, marking a welcome step toward transparency in the murky waters of campaign finance.
The state’s new rule mandates donor disclosure from 501(c)4 nonprofit groups if their communications are distributed within 30 days of an election and are “susceptible to no other reasonable interpretation than to urge the passage or defeat” of a candidate or ballot measure.
These shadowy players—politically active nonprofits—are not subject to federal disclosure requirements, which has created a secretive financial arms race in which limitless money is funneled into campaigns with no accountability whatsoever.
In Texas, none of these groups is more infamous than Empower Texans, a conservative political advocacy group (also known as Texans for Fiscal Responsibility) headed by Dallas Morning News’s 2014 “Texan of the Year” finalist Michael Quinn Sullivan. Empower Texans claims that its primary purpose is not to engage in political activity but rather to promote fiscal responsibility in the state—a questionable assertion given that, according to state records, the group has spent nearly $900,000 in direct political expenditures since 2012. The Texas Ethics Commission has taken direct aim at Empower Texans, filing a lawsuit against the group for failing to disclose its donors the same day the disclosure rule passed.
The new Texas rule supplants a previous, decades-old standard that allowed 501(c)4 groups like Empower Texans to sidestep disclosure so long as they pass a “magic words” test in communication materials—not using overtly political words such as “vote,” “elect,” “against”—that would otherwise qualify as political activity.
Magic, indeed. This narrow guideline was easy enough for these groups to follow, allowing their donors to stay hidden while still circulating content that was clearly advocacy. For example, Empower Texans’ February 2014 ad opposing Republican Texas House member Jim Keffer doesn’t explicitly direct viewers to vote “for” or “against” Keffer, but instead to “fire” him. Such cloaked anonymity creates a shadowy, uneven political playing field rife with wealth and secrecy that leaves voters unaware of who is trying to influence them and why.
Though a shade more subjective than the prior “magic words” test criterion, this new regulation is a small but significant stride toward more honest elections in the state.
More states should follow the Texas Ethics Commission’s lead in cleaning up campaign spending and eradicating any legal loopholes.
More Blog Posts
It’s pretty rich for the Republican Attorneys General Association to criticize anyone for taking “special interest” money. The Republican Attorneys General Association is funded by special interests who the next attorney general of Kentucky will oversee. It’s not hard to see. Just follow the money. Read More ›
H&R Block, the nation’s second largest paid tax preparer, is currently under fire for lobbying to make it harder for taxpayers to apply for the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), which is considered an important tool for lifting working Americans out of poverty. Specifically, the company pushed for the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to significantly increase the number of questions self-filers have to answer in order to claim the credit, most of which paid preparers are already required to answer. But what may be more egregious is just how they lobbied for this change. Read More ›
So far in 2015, NFL team owners have donated $2,827,804 in support of presidential candidates. The vast majority of the money came from two GOP mega donors and went to a handful of Republican super PACs. In all, nine team owners have invested in the 2016 election. Read More ›
September 11, 2015 | Elections
Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) filed a complaint last month asking the IRS to look into whether CMP violated federal law by misrepresenting its planned activities in its application for tax-exempt status. This week we received CMP’s application from the IRS, and it provides yet more examples of deceptive conduct by the organization. Read More ›
Georgia-based Jackson Healthcare, part of the Job Creators Network (JCN), has not only given more than $500,000 to Jeb Bush's super PAC, they are using the E2E program to influence how their employees vote. Read More ›